Patricia Crone & Michael Cook HAGARISM The Making of the Islamic World HAGARISM THE MAKING OF THE ISLAMIC WORLD PATRICIA CRONE SENIOR . 13 Mar A classic “revisionist” work on the formation of Islam. Identifier Hagarism. Identifier-ark ark://t2w40bp6s. Ocr ABBYY FineReader This is a paperback edition of a controversial study of the origins of Islamic civilisation, first published in By examining non-Muslim sources, the authors.
|Published (Last):||7 June 2004|
|PDF File Size:||20.32 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||3.37 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The core of Samaritanism was the rejection of the sanctity of Jerusalem and its replacement by the older Israelite sanctuary of Shechem. Two features of the Mosaic complex facilitated this alignment. This is a controversial study of the origins of Islamic civilisation that examines non-Muslim sources that point out an intimate link between the Jewish religion and the earliest forms of Islam. Get fast, free shipping with Amazon Prime. True, a messianic king shall come worrld from Baalbek, but only at the end of times when we shall all be dead; and in the meantime one wordly polity is likely to be as good as another.
The quondam barbarians thus acquired a share in the government of the empire, while the imperial government conversely acquired greater local ramifications.
Hagarism; The Making Of The Islamic World Crone, Cook
The books lakes any clear criteria or interanl coherent logic to start from givens to conclusions. In any case, with the single exception of a passage in the dialogue between the pftriarch and the emir which tbe be construed as an im- plicit reference to the Koranic law of inheritance, 20 there is no indication of the existence of the Koran before the end of iskamic seventh century.
This is a fascinating section of the book, as it depicts the struggles that took place and continue to take place within the Muslim world over what to do with the pre-existing ideas that were present in the lands they conquered.
Like Egypt and Assyria, Syria developed its own provincial Christianity, dis- tinguished from islwmic rest of the Christian world by a heresy on the one hand and a monasticism of its own peculiar breed on the other. Thus the Hagarenes contrived to create a religion of their own and decided to splinter off from Judaic practices and beliefs.
Cambridge University Press February 29, Language: This story generally follows a pattern which, it seems, is universally accepted by Muslims, and given that Quran does not give much information about the contexts of the Revelations, it is interesting to see the similarity of the contextual information different Islamic makng w As, generally speaking, is the case with every child who was born and raised in a Muslim country, I am more or less familiar with the life of Prophet Muhammad and with the main events in the story of the rise of Islam.
Hagarism begins hagarizm the hagariam that Western historical scholarship on the beginnings of Islam should be based on contemporary historical, archaeological and philological data, as is done for the study of Judaism and Christianity, rather than Islamic traditions and later Arabic writings. Cover of the first edition. In each case, the tendency on the Hagarene side is clearly towards the Samaritan scriptural position.
For an occurrence of the phrase ahl al-islam in an inscription hagairsm a h. In the second place, Yahweh ‘s ethnic past lay outside the civilisation which had now adopted him. Such a hypothesis would go well with the prominence of the north-west in the rather meagre Arabian geography of the Koran, 24 and would make sense of some anomalous indications in ot Islamic tradition that the sanctuary was at one stage located to the north of Medina.
But once freed from the distractions of the polis, the philosophers returned to the abiding problems of the universe.
Full text of “Hagarism; The Making Of The Islamic World Crone, Cook”
It is here that the authors present their thesis that there are no cogent grounds for accepting the historicity of the Islamic tradition, and that because of the unreliability of these traditions, it is necessary to step outside of them and start over with non-Islamic sources, such as the writings of Jews and Christians living around the time of the conquests pg.
The Syrians were children of Christianity as the Pakistanis are children of Islam: Furthermore, it must be admitted that something original whatever it may have been must have developed in the Arabian peninsula; something which would meld with existing ideas to form Islam as it is known today.
But equally, Iraq had no pillar saints: My reservations here, and elsewhere in this first part of the book, turn upon what I take to be the authors’ methodological assumptions, of which the principal must be that a vocabulary of motives can be freely extrapolated from a discrete collection of literary stereotypes havarism by alien and mostly hostile observers, and thereupon employed to describe, even interpret, not merely the overt behaviour but also intellectual and spiritual development of the helpless and mostly innocent actors.
It might hagaridm be superfluous for us to attempt a defence of this enter- prise against the raised eyebrows of the specialist, but it would certainly be pointless: We now reach an area for which Jewish tbe is well makibg in pre-Islamic times, and for which a sacred geography had hagarrism been sketched out in the Jewish Targums.
Hagarism : the making of the Islamic world
Hence they are biased towards ideas that developed after the events described cf. Don’t have an account?
tne The Islamic tradition, of course, leaves us in no doubt that Mecca was the aboriginal Abrahamic sanctuary of the Ishma- Whence Islam? Learn more about Amazon Prime. In the first place, a shift from a prophetology more reactionary than Judaism to one more progressive than Christianity brought the older monotheist religions into a more comfortable perspective. The lack of contemporary Islamic sources for the study hatarism this period determines the strategy of Hagarism: There was thus a certain similarity between the Syria of A.
Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic World by Patricia Crone
There is moreover one late midrashic source which provides a suggestive parallel. Strange Tales of Scotland. It was a transposition into a lower key, a shift from momentary frenzy to institu- tional permanence, but it was not in itself an unhappy one. These mosques are oriented too far north by 33 degrees and 30 degrees respectively; 24 and with this we may compare the literary testimony to the “effect that the Iraqi qibla lay to the west.
The Hagarenes had achieved a new, independent and effective solution to a central dilemma of learned monotheism; and with this their undignified clientage to the peoples they had conquered was finally at an end.
Julian sacrificed at the hands of a Syrian priest, and the Syrian priest sent his son to a Greek school; the emperors re- warded Syrian hagarixm with local office, and the Syrian provincials took a Graeco- Roman education. Add a review and share your thoughts with other readers. Only love the God of Abraham, go and take possession of your country which God gave to your father Abraham, tbe none will be able to resist you in the struggle, for God is with you.
It is true that the ghost of Babylon haunted lower Iraq for some two centuries in the shape of the client kingdom of Mesene which, though founded by an Iranian satrap, soon went Aramaic; 78 and there were no doubt other Aramean kings under the Parthians.
But for the provincials of the Near East Graeco- Roman culture was neither the inevitable nor indeed the most desirable form in which civilisation could present itself on earth; and if cultural permissiveness had enabled them to preserve their own identity, cultural imperiousness now forced them to assert it actively against the metro- politan culture, or to restate it within it.
Just as it was they who, on eating of too many trees of knowledge, had suffered the most disastrous cognitive fall, so it was they who were plagued with the most obsessive and ghoulish intruders from worlds unknown. When redemption became scripture, the Hagarenes found themeselves in need of an Arabian Sinai. Paperbackpages. Hence they are biased towards ideas that developed after the events described cf. Given that, however, their messianism was the defining attribute of their religion and it was deeply connected to the quest for Canaan, which made this messianism Jewish, the Believers needed now to break this connection.
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item? In the second place, Christianity changed the cognitive structure of the empire, depriving the mandarins of their monopoly on truth.
Given the consistency of the accounts about the rise of Islam, it seems that there is not much reason to doubt the authenticity of these narratives, except one crucial feature of the Islamic sources: Against this background, the Macedonian kings could pose as the avengers of Hellenism against the Persians and act as its protectors in distant lands ; but these roles remained external to a tradition within which the Hellenistic monarchies possessed no authentic intrinsic status.
The harder they leant on Christianity to dissociate them- selves from the Jews, the greater the danger that they would simply end up by becoming Christians like the majority of their subjects. More generally, the espousal of the Pentateuch without the prophets defined an attitude to the question of religious authority, at least in its scriptural form, which was polemically viable in the monotheist world.